From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Barlow v. Benfield

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Mar 1, 1950
58 S.E.2d 637 (N.C. 1950)

Opinion

Filed 29 March, 1950.

1. Public Officers 1 — The office of chief of police of an incorporated town is a public office.

2. Elections 18a — The qualified voters and taxpayers of a municipality may maintain quo warranto to determine the right of incumbent to hold a municipal office.

3. Municipal Corporations 11a, 11 1/2 b — A person not a resident of an incorporated municipality may not be elected chief of police by the board of commissioners of the municipality. G.S. 160-25.

APPEAL by relators from Rudisill, J., November Term, 1949, of CALDWELL. Reversed.

Martin Carpenter for plaintiffs, appellants.

L. M. Abernethy and Max C. Wilson for defendant, appellee.


This was an action in the nature of quo warranto to determine the right of defendant Benfield to hold the office of chief of police of Granite Falls.

At the close of plaintiffs' evidence, motion for judgment of nonsuit was allowed, and relators excepted and appealed.


The judgment of nonsuit was improvidently entered. It was made to appear from the admissions in the answer and the evidence offered by the relators that 1 July, 1949, the defendant was elected by the Board of Commissioners of Granite Falls as chief of police of that town, which office he is now holding, and that defendant is not a qualified voter therein. It was also admitted that relators are residents, qualified voters, and taxpayers of Granite Falls.

The office of chief of police of an incorporated town, as Granite Falls is admitted to be, is a public office. Foard v. Hall, 111 N.C. 369, 16 S.E. 420. The relators had a right to institute this action for the cause et out in the complaint. Bouldin v. Davis, 197 N.C. 731, 150 S.E. 507; Midgett v. Gray, 158 N.C. 133, 73 S.E. 791. The statute (G.S. 160-25) provides that "No person shall be mayor, commissioner, intendant of police, alderman or other chief officer of any city or town unless he shall be a qualified voter therein." This statute, said Chief Justice Clark in Foard v. Hall, supra, "embraces the office of chief of police."

The judgment of nonsuit must be vacated.

Reversed.


Summaries of

Barlow v. Benfield

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Mar 1, 1950
58 S.E.2d 637 (N.C. 1950)
Case details for

Barlow v. Benfield

Case Details

Full title:STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA EX REL. RALPH BARLOW AND JACK MOORE v. C. O…

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Mar 1, 1950

Citations

58 S.E.2d 637 (N.C. 1950)
58 S.E.2d 637

Citing Cases

State v. Hord

Green v. Kitchin, 229 N.C. 450, 50 S.E.2d 545. Moreover, G.S. 160-21 provides: "A policeman shall have the…

State ex Rel. Webb v. Cianci

Additionally the court in Goff v. Hunt, 6 N.J. 600, 605, 80 A.2d 104, 106 (1951), wrote that "[a] taxpayer…