From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Ballard v. Ballard

Oregon Supreme Court
Dec 19, 1962
377 P.2d 25 (Or. 1962)

Opinion

Argued December 6, 1962

Affirmed December 19, 1962

Appeal from the Circuit Court, Benton County, FRED McHENRY, Judge.

Robert Mix, Corvallis, argued the cause and filed a brief for appellant.

James W. Walton, Corvallis, argued the cause for respondent. On the brief were Ringo Walton, Corvallis.

Before McALLISTER, Chief Justice, and O'CONNELL, GOODWIN, LUSK and DENECKE, Justices.


AFFIRMED.


This is an appeal by the wife from a divorce decree which awarded custody of two minor children to their paternal grandmother.

There is nothing unlawful per se in placing a minor child in the custody of one who is not a party to the unfortunate marriage. See Watson v. Watson, 213 Or. 182, 323 P.2d 335, 221 Or. 138, 350 P.2d 694. The Watson case indicates that such a placement ordinarily should not be considered permanent.

The appellant is challenging the trial court's finding that she is unfit to have custody, however, and only incidentally its finding that the best interests of the children would be served by placing them in the home of their grandmother. We assume that when one of the parents becomes able to provide a suitable environment for the children, the court will give the matter appropriate consideration.

The evidence, which need not be set forth in detail, fully discloses a foundation for the trial court's belief that the mother was incapable of providing a proper home for the children. Her incapacity may not have been caused exclusively by her moral inadequacies, but it is nonetheless real. The affair she was having with the man who wanted to supplant the father was only one symptom of her immaturity. The trial judge no doubt considered the others. In such matters the decision of the trial judge is entitled to great weight. Shrout v. Shrout, 224 Or. 521, 356 P.2d 935.

Affirmed; neither party to recover costs.


Summaries of

Ballard v. Ballard

Oregon Supreme Court
Dec 19, 1962
377 P.2d 25 (Or. 1962)
Case details for

Ballard v. Ballard

Case Details

Full title:BALLARD v. BALLARD

Court:Oregon Supreme Court

Date published: Dec 19, 1962

Citations

377 P.2d 25 (Or. 1962)
377 P.2d 25

Citing Cases

Mackey v. Mackey

" In custody proceedings the findings of the trial court are to be afforded great weight, Ballard v. Ballard,…

A. v. A.

In child custody proceedings this court reviews de novo; however, the decision of the trial court is afforded…