Opinion
January 28, 1926.
Appeal from the Municipal Court, Brooklyn, Sixth District.
Joseph B. Merkert, for the appellant.
Emanuel Mehl, for the respondent
Present, CROPSEY, MacCRATE and LEWIS, JJ.
Judgment and order unanimously reversed upon the law, with thirty dollars costs to appellant to abide the event, and motion denied, with ten dollars costs.
There is nothing to show when the defendant's term ended, and as he moved out on May twenty-ninth, there is no basis shown for the recovery of the June rent. According to the defendant's affidavit the May rent was paid by the plaintiff's accepting and using the security which the defendant had previously put up, the use of the security for this purpose being by agreement between the parties. While the defendant has pleaded only a general denial and has not pleaded payment, or surrender and acceptance, still where facts are shown in an affidavit opposing a motion for summary judgment which would constitute a defense if properly pleaded, the motion cannot prevail. ( Curry v. Mackenzie, 239 N.Y. 267; Melcher, Inc., v. Graziano, 212 A.D. 589.)
There is nothing to show that the lease was a part of the motion papers. But if it was it does not help the plaintiff. On the face of the lease its term of ending is not stated. The provision in it to the effect that no surrender of the premises shall arrest the payment of rent, unless the surrender be accepted in writing by the landlord, does not prevent acceptance and surrender without a writing by the landlord. This provision may be waived by the latter.