Summary
In Adams v. State, (1972) 259 Ind. 164, 165, 284 N.E.2d 757, 758 (opinion on rehearing) it was in response to the holding in Furman v. Georgia which left the constitutionality of the statute under which he was convicted and sentenced uncertain.
Summary of this case from Brewer v. StateOpinion
No. 369S41.
Filed July 25, 1972.
TRIAL COURT — Death Sentence — Case Must Be Remanded and Sentence Vacated. — Where appellant was found guilty of murder in the first degree and sentenced to death by the trial court, the Indiana Supreme Court must remand the case to the trial court with directions to vacate its sentence imposing the death penalty and in lieu thereof impose a life sentence. This mandate is necessary because of the United states Supreme Court decisions of June 29, 1972, holding that the death penalty was unconstitutional in certain cases before it, while not delineating any standards for determining when said penalty might possibly be constitutional.
From the Grant Circuit Court, Manuel P. Guerrero, Judge.
This case involves the infliction of the death penalty as a result of a guilty verdict of murder in the first degree. The judgment of the trial court was affirmed by the Indiana Supreme Court to which appellant filed a petition for rehearing raising the constitutionality of the death penalty.
Rehearing granted and mandate issued.
C.W.H. Bangs, H.D. Rollo, Bangs, Mills Rollo, of Huntington, for appellant.
Theodore L. Sendak, Attorney General, Robert F. Hassett, Deputy Attorney General, for appellee.
This case involves the infliction of the death penalty on the appellant as the result of his being found guilty of murder in the first degree, having killed the companion of a girl whom he also raped. We affirmed the judgment of the trial court which imposed the death penalty; DeBruler, J. concurring and dissenting with separate opinion, Prentice, J. concurring therein and also dissenting by separate opinion. Adams v. State (1971), 271 N.E.2d 425.
The appellant has filed a petition for rehearing raising the constitutionality of the death penalty. We have delayed ruling upon this petition pending the determination of the United States Supreme Court of that question.
On June 29, 1972, that Court handed down nine separate opinions, the majority of the Justices thereof holding that the death penalty was unconstitutional in the cases before it, but a majority not delineating any standards for determining when it might possibly be constitutional. Furman v. Georgia (June 29, 1972), Docket nos. 69-5003, 69-5030, 69-5031, 40 U.S.L.W. 4923.
Each justice having his own separate reason, Chief Justice Berger said:
"Since there is no majority of the Court on the ultimate issue presented in these cases, the future of capital punishment in this country has been left in an uncertain limbo." (Slip opinion at 29.)
In view of this uncertainty, we have no alternative but to remand this case to the trial court with directions to vacate its sentence imposing the death penalty and in lieu thereof impose a life sentence on the appellant. The petition for rehearing is granted and the mandate is issued accordingly.
All Justices concur.
NOTE. — Reported in 284 N.E.2d 757.