From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Abbott v. Abbott

Supreme Court of New Hampshire Merrimack
Feb 2, 1915
93 A. 460 (N.H. 1915)

Summary

In Schomaker a husband sued in equity to recover his separate property, and his wife counterclaimed (filed a "cross-bill") for a decree requiring her husband to keep an alleged agreement to pay her a fixed allowance as well as certain taxes on her real estate. The cross-bill was held to present "`questions... entirely distinct from those presented in the original bill....'" Schomaker v. Schomaker, supra at 448, 93 A. at 461.

Summary of this case from Olivieri v. Olivieri

Opinion

Decided February 2, 1915.

PETITION FOR PARTITION. At the April term, 1914, of the superior court, the plaintiff's motion that the answer to the petition be disallowed was denied by Branch, J., subject to exception.

Joseph S. Matthews (by brief and orally), for the plaintiff.

George V. Hill (by brief and orally), for the defendant.


It was conceded at the argument that there was no legal objection to a physical partition of the premises. Whether the premises can be so divided is a question of fact for the trial court. Laws 1913, c. 21, s. 3. As there appears to be little, if any, doubt that in fact such division can be made without great prejudice or inconvenience, ordinary convenience in procedure requires the determination of that question before discussion of the proposition whether upon the facts stated a sale of the whole can be ordered.

Case discharged.


Summaries of

Abbott v. Abbott

Supreme Court of New Hampshire Merrimack
Feb 2, 1915
93 A. 460 (N.H. 1915)

In Schomaker a husband sued in equity to recover his separate property, and his wife counterclaimed (filed a "cross-bill") for a decree requiring her husband to keep an alleged agreement to pay her a fixed allowance as well as certain taxes on her real estate. The cross-bill was held to present "`questions... entirely distinct from those presented in the original bill....'" Schomaker v. Schomaker, supra at 448, 93 A. at 461.

Summary of this case from Olivieri v. Olivieri
Case details for

Abbott v. Abbott

Case Details

Full title:ELLEN S. ABBOTT v. ISABEL F. ABBOTT

Court:Supreme Court of New Hampshire Merrimack

Date published: Feb 2, 1915

Citations

93 A. 460 (N.H. 1915)
93 A. 460

Citing Cases

Olivieri v. Olivieri

Rule 1510, Pa.R.C.P., Rule 1509, Pa.R.C.P., Rule 1017(b)(5), Pa.R.C.P. Rule 1510(a) provides in relevant…

T. C. R. Realty, Inc. v. Cox

Prior to the Equity Rules of 1925, a defendant in equity could assert a claim against the plaintiff by a…